I’m tackling this one head-on, so here goes. First, I believe that, because money runs much of the world, vaccines are being pushed more than necessary. Profit drives pharmaceuticals, medical care, hospitals, medical schools, and on and on. This makes me suspicious of the recommendations of anyone, including those who would traditionally be considered credible, such as medical doctors and the CDC. It also makes me question whether putting all of those vaccines into my little baby’s body is the best thing for her. I have questioned vaccines much more than my doctor would probably like.
I also believe that the benefit of at least some vaccines has been scientifically proven beyond almost all doubt. I personally know people who have been tragically affected by polio and measles. The near eradication of those diseases is (was) miraculous, and questioning whether those vaccines are necessary because it’s trendy to do so is a privilege only allowed those of us who have never lived in third-world conditions where parents would literally give their lives to have access to vaccines that would protect their children. So…I bet you’re wondering: is she pro-vax or anti-vax? You probably just want to skip to the end to find out. And that’s the problem.
The media, as usual, has done an excellent job of turning the vaccine issue into a black-and-white, polarizing one. Are you pro-vax or anti-vax? WELL???? I’ll tell you what I am. I’m pro-science. Not any science, because we all know you can make a study or a statistic say anything you want. I’m pro- good, solid evidence proven repeatedly through the scientific method. Remember when we learned about that in school? Double-blind studies? Peer review? The placebo effect? Validity? Reliability? All those things that make a credible study? That’s what I’m interested in, and I have to be honest—sometimes I don’t know where to find it anymore. We now have a board-certified cardiologist here in Arizona spewing how vaccines are toxic. You will note, however, that his diatribe fails to ever name a reliable source other than something generic like, “Ask the CDC!” If he has a valid source, I am really interested, but so far he seems to just want to drive traffic to his web site. We have bloggers giving their opinions as though they are facts, saying things like, “Studies show that vaccines are toxic, and here are three stories of kids who died after getting the ABC vaccine.” I think most of these bloggers believe what they’re saying, but WE SHOULDN’T. It’s just an opinion; consider it, follow up on it, ask questions, but don’t blindly rely on it. Even what you read in books is just an opinion unless every single sentence is cited with a source that you can verify. Look, I’m guilty, too. I am moved by Jenny McCarthy’s story, and I think she genuinely found what worked for her son. Good for her—she was a relentless, loving mama. But her story shouldn't dictate mine. Or when I read that ten kids some blogger knew showed signs of autism within 2 months of getting the MMR vaccine, it terrifies me. As a mama and a human being, my immediate reaction is to keep my kid as far away from that vaccine as possible, just in case. But that approach is neither rational nor supported, and it’s my responsibility as a mother not to make choices based on knee-jerk, solely emotional reactions.
Am I pro-vax or anti-vax? I will not be cornered into answering a question that forces me to take an ignorant position. Currently, as more reliable information emerges, I will continue to weigh the costs and benefits. After doing the best research I’ve been able to do and taking my emotions out of it as much as possible, the benefits of most vaccines far outweigh the proven risks in my opinion. If more risks are credibly proven in the future, my opinion may change. I also modified our vaccine schedule because it seemed like a low-risk way to avoid putting too many drugs into my child at one time for my own peace of mind. I will never, however, be pro-vax or anti-vax, because I will always be open to new information. I am pro-science. REAL science. In my opinion, a subtle war on science is being waged by those who profit from it. It is now an opinion to “believe in” science, which is just what many corporations and politicians want because it makes it easier to control us. If science is just one of many options of things to believe in, then it puts science on an even keel with a blog post. Or a novel. Or a fairy tale. Or…wait for it…an advertisement.
My advice? AND IT’S JUST MY ADVICE! I am just some woman sitting here typing in yoga pants—don’t blindly believe me or anyone else! My advice is to not take a pro- or anti-vaccine stance. Don’t buy into the crap. Be pro-science. Pro-information. Pro-asking-questions. Pro-thinking. Pro-people. Pro-health. Pro-community. Pro-responsibility. It is infinitely more effective.